To the Editor.—Dr David Austin1 is to be commended for his courageous second look at adenotonsillectomy visa-vis chronic serous otitis media/recurrent bacterial otitis media. A number of senior otolaryngologists have, for decades, advocated an adenotonsillectomy approach to recurrent bacterial otitis media. Their work was, unfortunately, drowned out by the rush to tympanostomy tube placement. In a way, the tympanostomy tube with its complications of otorrhea, extrusion, cholesterol pearl formation, and persistent perforations represents a double-edged sword. Crying, traumatized, unhappy pediatric otologic patients have "enslaved" two generations of otolaryngologists.
Adenotonsillectomy has proven to be the procedure of choice for the following conditions:
upper airway compromise2-4
obstructive sleep apnea2,5,6
upper airway compromise with secondary cor pulmonale2,7
aberrant dentofacial development8-10
recurrent bacterial adenotonsillitis
chronic serous otitis media/bacterial otitis media
some cases of enuresis
excessive daytime sleepiness3
retarded intellectual and physical growth3
It is indeed unfortunate that third-party health insurance carriers pay so poorly for such a wonderful procedure. When an